The dispute between Kelly Clarkson and a Brooklyn store regarding a mechanical bird has escalated, with a new asking price of $15 million.
Adam Rubin, co-owner of Art of Play, decided to put the store’s automated bird, known as “Molly,” on the market for an astounding $15 million US, amid the ongoing viral clash with the singer, as reported by USA Today.
The shop’s listing now states: “Molly. Crafted by Bliss Kolb. The world’s most renowned singing bird automaton! $15,000,000.”
Rubin mentioned to USA Today that if the bird sells, he would give each of the store’s employees $15,000 US and pay Kolb $1 million US. He indicated that the remaining funds would be used to acquire other antique automata.
CBC News has contacted Art of Play for verification but has yet to receive a response.
This development is the latest chapter in a story that has captivated the internet. It marks a significant rise from the $15,000 US price that Clarkson claims she observed during her visit to the shop on October 10.
‘Kelly Clarkson has put us in danger’: shop owner
Rubin spoke with multiple media outlets at Art of Play on Tuesday, stating that the shop has experienced a surge in visitors due to the publicity but has also faced significant backlash from the pop star’s fans.
“Kelly Clarkson has put us at risk,” Rubin stated. “We have concerns for our shopkeepers’ safety.”
Footage of Clarkson’s viral shopping experience was shared by independent journalist Pablo Torre on Tuesday, October 13.
The four-minute and 50-second video lacks audio. In it, Clarkson can be seen entering the store wearing a baseball cap and a yellow T-shirt. She browses the merchandise and seems to engage with a clerk, who speaks to her before walking away.
Later in the clip, Clarkson appears to return the items she was holding to the shelves and has a brief conversation with the cashier before exiting the store.
Origins of the conflict
The online controversy began on Saturday when Clarkson revealed she visited the shop to buy “a few items,” but felt “looked at as if I couldn’t afford it.”
“But you all should visit Art of Play in Brooklyn if you enjoy being treated like Julia Roberts’ character in Pretty Woman,” she tweeted.
For reference, Roberts’ character in the film is notoriously disrespected by a pretentious saleswoman in a boutique.
In response, the store stated on Sunday that Clarkson had inquired about purchasing “Molly,” the unique singing and dancing bird automaton that is “permanently affixed to the wall and not for sale.”
They acknowledged that Clarkson’s account of the incident “might resonate with anyone who has ever felt judged,” but emphasized that all customers at Art of Play “are equally welcome.”
“Imagine our astonishment when our small local business was suddenly attacked by eight million individuals who have never set foot in our shop,” the store posted on Instagram.
Clarkson responded later that day, sharing a photo of a $15,000 US price tag next to the wooden bird automaton.
“So not only are you rude, but you are also deceitful. […] It’s not difficult to be kind. I rarely call people out, but you, my friend, were an exception,” the singer remarked.
Clarkson seldom posts personal content on social media. Her last post on X was two weeks prior and promoted her coaching role on NBC’s The Voice.
On Monday, the store announced that it had informed Clarkson that the $15,000 US price referred to a similar bird that could be crafted and sold, not Molly herself.
The shop also mentioned that it had offered to show Clarkson another bird automaton priced around $2,000 US, but she left before having the chance to see it.
In an interview with various media outlets, Rubin stated that no one recognized Clarkson during her visit, the store was “crowded,” and she was there for “less than five minutes.” He also claimed that Clarkson reprimanded an employee.
“Everyone can have an off day. However, things escalated when she utilized her platform to attack us. It’s asymmetrical social warfare,” he remarked.
Public reaction
Users on social media have been closely monitoring the unfolding situation and expressing their opinions.
“This Kelly Clarkson situation exemplifies why everyone should work a retail job at some point in their lives, because once you do, you will never again scrutinize how store employees treat you,” wrote one user on X.
“Even if you accept Kelly Clarkson’s entire narrative, this doesn’t seem like a typical Pretty Woman situation,” commented another, adding that “it seems entirely reasonable that whoever she interacted with was not primarily focused on selling it or expected to do so.”

Molly, the singing and dancing mechanical bird by Bliss Kolb, is exhibited at Art of Play in Brooklyn, New York, on Tuesday. (Yuki Iwamura/The Associated Press)
“The most amusing aspect of this situation is that for anyone to take a side, they must either empathize with multimillionaire celebrity Kelly Clarkson or these multimillionaire shop owners,” another user expressed.
“The lesson from the Kelly Clarkson and Art of Play situation is that if any customer inquires about the price of your product, the right approach is not to discriminate based on their appearance,” stated another user.
Tag: rewrite-pending

