As discussions intensify regarding a new agreement for Churchill Falls, a former civil servant with extensive experience believes that one new provision could significantly benefit Newfoundland and Labrador.
According to a report by allNewfoundlandLabrador, the updated agreement includes a guaranteed transmission capacity of 985 megawatts via Quebec. This provision allows Newfoundland and Labrador to export up to that amount of electricity generated from the Churchill River through Hydro-Quebec’s transmission infrastructure to other markets. For instance, if Massachusetts requires power, Newfoundland and Labrador could facilitate that sale.
The earlier Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) for Churchill Falls did not provide any guarantees for transmission access, meaning Quebec would have the priority to use any energy earmarked for Newfoundland and Labrador that wasn’t utilized within the province.
CBC has verified this information through a source familiar with the agreement who is not permitted to speak publicly.
Ron Penney stated that if the transmission access deal is accurate, “It would indeed represent a significant and beneficial change for us.”
Ron Penney expresses doubts that there is enough time to transform the MOU into a formal legal agreement between the provinces in the coming weeks. (CBC)
This would represent a significant advantage for Premier Tony Wakeham, who has emphasized the necessity for the deal to prioritize the interests of the province.
“I remain focused on ensuring the long-term best interests of our province are upheld, with my main priority being to guarantee that Newfoundlanders and Labradorians are the primary beneficiaries of our resources,” Wakeham stated in January.
CBC News has reached out to Wakeham for an interview and is waiting for a reply.
In the meantime, Quebec Premier Christine Fréchette conveyed in French to reporters in Montreal on Thursday that securing a deal is crucial for her province’s long-term energy stability.
“Negotiations have really picked up pace in recent days, and I feel confident that we could finalize a deal and sign something shortly,” she remarked.
Not finalized yet
Penney indicated that although the details of a Churchill Falls agreement might be disclosed soon, the journey to a binding contract remains complicated.
On Wednesday, sources who are not authorized to speak publicly confirmed to CBC News that a new memorandum of understanding is nearing completion. They indicated that two or three issues remain unresolved, but progress is being made, with both governments aiming for a formal announcement early next week.
Sources indicate that a potential new agreement concerning the Churchill River is approaching completion, which could replace the 2024 MOU. However, Premier Tony Wakeham’s office has stated that no final agreement has been executed, leading the Liberals and NDP to seek clarity regarding the deal’s outcome. CBC’s Cameron Kilfoy reports.
Penney, who previously served as deputy minister of justice and has criticized the contentious Muskrat Falls hydroelectric initiative, noted that he is not surprised by the prospect of a deal, citing “political pressures” on Fréchette as she approaches an election that must be called by August 29.
“Clearly, she is under considerable pressure. Likewise, we face pressure because the prior MOU would have provided us with immediate annual cash flow, which we urgently need,” Penney told CBC Radio’s The St. John’s Morning Show.
However, he cautioned that the situation in Quebec adds complexity to the negotiations.
“I believe we should temper our enthusiasm even if the agreement is signed, as polls indicate that the PQ is likely to form the next government in Quebec, and they oppose the current MOU,” Penney remarked.
He also expressed that negotiations cannot occur during an election period, making it “impractical” for the MOU to be converted into a legal agreement, a process that could take months.
-
New Churchill Falls deal between N.L. and Quebec being finalized: sources
-
Quebec-Labrador border is becoming political fodder
“Whether that will actually happen remains very uncertain,” Penney added.
He stated that it is also essential to wait and see the specifics of what the MOU entails.
Eager for details: Liberals
Liberal Leader John Hogan expressed optimism regarding the likelihood of a favorable deal.
“We are still not certain if an agreement is finalized. Reports suggest that a few issues need to be concluded before we can review it next week,” he stated. “However, we are looking forward to examining the agreement to understand precisely what Newfoundland and Labrador stands to gain.”
His party is not inclined to oppose a deal solely for political reasons, he noted, and he hopes that the premier and relevant ministers will be available to discuss the MOU’s content. He also advocates for a debate in the House of Assembly, similar to the process followed for the previous MOU.
Sources indicate that a new Churchill Falls deal is nearing its final stages. (CBC)
Similar to Penney, Hogan raised concerns about the limited timeframe for securing a deal and the impending Quebec election.
NDP Leader Jim Dinn suggested that a promised referendum on the MOU is unlikely to materialize.
“I have always thought that a referendum, as the PCs envisioned it, was incredibly naive and poorly advised,” he told CBC News.
He noted that a referendum would necessitate a public engagement element to ensure that individuals are informed, which he argued has not occurred.
NDP Leader Jim Dinn is advocating for a special debate in the House of Assembly regarding the MOU. (Darryl Murphy/CBC)
Dinn emphasized that a special debate in the House of Assembly on the MOU is necessary, similar to the approach taken for the previous MOU, with experts invited to contribute.
“Let’s have a thorough discussion so that the public can listen and pose their questions,” he stated.
In a statement from the NDP earlier on Thursday, Dinn expressed his desire to know whether the Innu Nation had been consulted regarding the new MOU.
Download our free CBC News appto sign up for push alerts for CBC Newfoundland and Labrador. Sign up for our daily headlines newsletter here. Click here to visit our landing page.